They are assigned because their inherent qualities accord with the inherent qualities of the planet in question. Both the mineral and its color represent attributes of its ruling planet. With Vedic gem prescription, people are not divided into twelve groups with everyone in a group getting the same gemstone assigned. Rather, gemstones are prescribed on an individual basis after looking at the entire horoscope of an individual. It is understood that the right gemstone can alleviate suffering and contribute to success, prosperity and harmony while the wrong gemstone can have the opposite effect.
It depends on the placement of the planets in the horoscope. Such a prescription is best done by a knowledgeable expert. Thank you Alison for a clear explanation about the differences and similarities between Vedic Astrology and modern Western Astrology. I look forward to more enlightening blogs from you. Like Like. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account.
You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. Skip to content. Share this: Email Tweet. Like this: Like Loading Jay Boyle Like Like. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:. Email required Address never made public.
- Western vs. Eastern: a comparison.
- 2020 monthly horoscope libra born 8 march.
- born 13 february horoscope 2020.
- Post navigation!
Name required. Learn More.
- Thanks for Subscribe.
- What is Your New Astrology™ Sign?.
- aries born march 3 horoscope?
- Navigation menu.
- Planetary time periods....
Western Astrology. Chinese Astrology. New Astrology.
Double Horoscopes. Celeb Stars.
The 12 Signs
Suze's Blog. This is seen by them as"scoring points", i. This type of information is also of less value to many Western astrological clients, who are often more interested in psychological issues and the unfolding of life's lessons and opportunities; and so Western astrologers have come to speak to their clients' interests. This orientation may also be a side effect of the Western cultural derision towards astrology, which would sway many practical people away from consulting astrologers.
Western astrologers, nevertheless, have made innumerable successful mundane predictions. Western clients do want to know when they will marry, move, or get a new job, and are happy with the work of their Western astrologers. Joan Quigley, for example, the astrologer of President Reagan and his wife, was very successful using Tropical Lunar Returns in predicting personal and World events.
One of the most influential financiers in history, J. Billionaires do", and attributed much of his success in business to the guidance he received from his Western astrologer. Finally, Judith Hill was able to predict the timing of earthquakes precisely, using her own innovative Western astrological methods.
Western criticisms of Vedic Astrology A. Some Western astrologers are so attached to their successes in using the Tropical Zodiac, that they too pronounce the use of the Sidereal Zodiac as erroneous. This is fallacious for the following reasons: 1.
Where did the signs get their names? From the shapes of the constellations in the sky. Clearly, the Sidereal Zodiac was used by astrologers far earlier than the Tropical Zodiac, and is the basis of the sign names and their meanings.ulspameslipa.tk
Sidereal and tropical astrology
Most Western astrologers have literally no knowledge of the principles of Vedic astrology, and therefore cannot understand how signs can be used differently and still have value. They shouldn't reject what they haven't explored. For example, Vedic astrologers know that if the dispositor of a planet occupying its weakest sign called Fall in Western astrology and Detriment in Vedic astrology is in its own sign or exaltation, then the original planet's weakness is ameliorated. Such fundamental understandings are missing from Western astrology. The Vedic system of astrology has been practiced by more astrologers, for much longer, than Western astrology.
To invalidate an entire system that has been developed from its inception based on the Sidereal Zodiac just because it uses a different coordinate system is completely misguided. It's very similar to someone ignorant of astrology deciding astrology doesn't work because the planets are so far away.
Within Western astrology there are so many different approaches that are accepted, from using different house systems, rulership methods, and additional points like the asteroids, the comet Chiron, and hypothetical points, as well as the variant principles used in Horary, to the different coordinate systems used for astro-mapping, and in Heliocentric astrology, and even in Western Sidereal astrology. If Western astrologers can tolerate the amazing diversity within their camp, they should be ecumenical enough to accept Vedic astrology, too.
Too Fatalistic. This is perhaps the most often voiced objection to Vedic astrology by Western astrologers ignorant of the field. They ignore the following facts: 1. Vedic astrologers can recommend specific forms of charity, chants, meditations, ceremonies, and gemstones to help to balance one's chart.
Chinese vs. Western Astrology: What Are the Differences?
If the Vedic method was fatalistic, applying remedial measures would never have become part of their tradition. Western astrology was originally so fatalistic itself that its fatalism was the cause of its rejection by early Christians, e. Saint Augustine in his Confessions. Many Western astrologers still use very fatalistic and very discouraging language. Fatalism is the flaw of the individual practitioner, not of the type of astrology. In other words, Vedic astrologers are generally much more willing to address dis-asters bad stars!
Another practice confused with fatalism is the teaching method common to both ancient Western and Vedic astrology that presented the most extreme manifestations as examples of a particular astrological factor. For example, from Ptolemy's classic Tetrabiblos translated by Robert Schmidt, Book III, page 54 : "Kronos [Saturn] makes the native cold of belly and full of phlegm and rheumatic, emaciated and weak and jaundiced, prone to dysentery and coughing and vomiting and colic and elephantiasis The very extremity and starkness of the ancient style of delineations was meant as an aid to memory.
And the concreteness of the statements gave them life and color. A cursory glance at a classical Vedic text, in other words, has given many a modern Western astrologer the wrong impression, of fatalism and dire predictions.
Western vs. Vedic Astrology: Different Systems, Different Gems
Not Psychological. An additional complaint made of Vedic astrology by Western astrologers is that it is not psychological. Those voicing this criticism have clearly not familiarized themselves with the delineations available in even the oldest Vedic astrology texts. Vedic astrology is very psychological, in some ways more directly addressing one's mental state than Western astrology.
Related eastern vs western astrology
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved